A story about racial discrimination in Quebec

I remember going to a “Quebecois” school in Quebec where I first learned about racial discrimination when I was younger. The difference between a “Canadian” school and a Quebecois school in Quebec is the Quebecois school generally had separatist influences, they are relatively less diverse than the Canadian schools, there is no trace of anything distinctly Canadian, and there is no assistance to students who do not speak French as a native language.

Canadian schools, on the other hand, had a diverse student body, had some programmes for non-French speaking students, and put down racism in their school by promoting multiculturalism. My early experiences were both at a Canadian (St. Lawrence School) and Quebecois school (Ecole Samuel-De Champlain) where I spent 2 years in each school when I was young.

The first instance of racism I experienced at a Quebec school called Ecole Samuel-De Champlain, was when I was entering the school in the morning. While I was walking to class, some French kid kept making “Ching-Chang-Chong” noises while looking at me while a few kids called me a “Chin-tok (Chink in French)”. The kids that were around me simply ignored it as if it was normal while a handful laughed. At another instance, some French kids beat me up, trashed the things in my bookbag, and told me to “Go back to China” in French because they felt immigrants were taking his parents’ jobs or diluting the Quebecois spirit.

Then there was that second grade teacher named Sylvie L, who still teaches in the school as a grade 1 teacher. At that time she was in her late thirties, and I learned later that her husband was unemployed. I knew when I was younger I was a bit of a troublemaker, but I always thought it was strange how she would only give stern warnings to the White kids in the class while throwing me out of her class for the entire day when I did something wrong. This was strange because I did similar things to the other kids, but I got a harsher punishment and she never called me back to class once she threw me out.

I think these things were related to immigration and that’s why I get disgusted when people opposed to immigration rabidly deny that the issue has a racist element to it. I can definitely say, it has a racist element since I had the luxury of experiencing it first-hand in Quebec, Canada.

I really don’t like talking about this part of my life but it is a crude reminder of who I am. It’s also a reason why I unlearned the French language, abandoned my Catholic faith, and one of the reasons why it took several years to come to terms with myself.

My experiences in America are much better than Quebec. Although there is more ignorance than rampant racism here compared to Quebec, I want to do what I can to eliminate negative racial stereotypes and explore what it means to be Asian-American.

8 Responses to “A story about racial discrimination in Quebec”

  1. ChinkTalk Says:

    You are witnessing the ugly side of nationalism. Pre 60’s French Quebec had a defeatist mentality, but since the Quiet Revolution, the French people are taking pride in their roots. Like with the rise of China, Chinese people worldwide are becoming conscious of their Chineseness. There are a lot of similarities between Quebec and China, both were suppressed by foreign powers and both are regaining their national pride. I sympathize with what you went through, you were a victim of the torrents of history. The US is a true superpower. The fact that a black person is able to run for president is a sign of a country that is able to provide world leadership in race issues.

  2. lifeinmotion Says:

    Obama needs to win before you can declare the US as a progressive country

  3. Mark Says:

    Hej!

    I’m sorry that happened to you.
    How did you unlearn French, btw?

    Cheers!

  4. lifeinmotion Says:

    1. Stop speaking it.
    2. Replace with another language
    3. Avoid French speakers

  5. Holliefromquebec Says:

    Hi,

    I am a bilingual (mother tongue english) 30 year old female born in Quebec, I have lived here for most of my life except for a few years which I have lived in the United States. For the last 2 years I have been living in a small north eastern town in Quebec. The reason for this move was to be closer to my mom who was really sick at the time. Since living here I have become extremely unhappy. The racial and sexist discrimination is worse than I ever could have thought. In the past I have lived in Montreal which is very multicultural. I have noticed discrimination before but like I have seen since I have moved away from Montreal. It is a complete shame that I am embarrassed to speak english because everyone stops around you and stares and this is not an over exaggeration, they literally stop and stare. Some even comment on it. I can’t find a job, it has been a year that I have been looking. I am an educated and completely bilingual individual with much experience under my belt and I can’t even get a position at the local store. I have tried everywhere. Hundreds of applications…no phone calls. I have never had this problem before, it has never taken more than a few days to get a response and eventually work. If someone mubbles something that you didn’t HEAR and you ask then politely if they can repeat, if the noticed that you have an accent, they will repeat what they said very nastly, like they are annoyed that you didn’t understand them even though it was only because you didn’t hear what they have said. They automatically assume that you didn’t understand. Apparently, according to the french I am not a Quebecer, I am Canadian because I am english. I guess that literally means that I was not born in Quebec…which I believe I was. So I would say I am provinceless. If Quebec would separate from Canada one day and I am no longer a Canadian what would I be…according to the french theory that would make me homeless. What would I say if some asked me my nationality, I would have to response I AM NOTHING. The whole thing that makes all these matters worse is that the Quebec government is the leader of this cult. The discrimination starts at the top and works its way down. If Quebec is part of Canada why aren’t all services bilingual. You can’t find any important information in English all french. Funny how you need French to work in Quebec but you don’t need english. Many Quebec companies service you in french and no english. There is so much more that I can vent about but my conclusion being is that I no longer have respect for Quebec (the leader (government) and its cult followers). Presently, I am sadly looking to move out of Quebec. It is sad only because i am going to be leaving everyone I know and love behind…this includes my mom. If I stay here my quality of life will be non existent. It already is. So be it.

  6. lifeinmotion Says:

    It’s so sad that Quebec’s xenophobia and alleged intolerance is now a provincial stereotype even joked upon in Canadian comedy shows: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkd9nCdJj6U

  7. Ming Says:

    I was born and grow up in China. I have been in Montreal Quebec for five years, and I feel very depressed about the discrimination I receive from where I work. I plan to leave Quebec, living under discrimination for the rest of life is a tragedy.

  8. lifeinmotion Says:

    There has been a culture war in Quebec: those who want the province to be progressive and tolerant like France and Canada and there are those who want to keep it “Pure and French”. It seems the latter is winning the culture war.


Leave a Reply